Mobiledia: Cell Phones
Google
Web Mobiledia.com

Find us on Facebook We're on Facebook! Take our fun What's Your Cell Phone? Quiz and get matched with the perfect cell phones for your lifestyle. It's scarily accurate!

Home > Cell Phone News > Chief Justice Denies Stay in BlackBerry Case Cell Phone News Feed

Chief Justice Denies Stay in BlackBerry Case


Thu Oct 27, 2005 7:43 am

The Supreme Court denied RIM's motion to stay further proceedings in the case until the U.S. Supreme Court decides whether it will accept an appeal of the decision in this case. The Supreme Court was not asked to, and did not decide, whether it ultimately will accept an appeal of the decision in this case. Rather, the Supreme Court merely decided that it would follow its normal course of allowing the District Court to decide whether and to what extent to continue the litigation in light of all relevant circumstances, including the prospect that the Supreme Court may decide to hear the case. The process by which the Supreme Court will decide whether to hear the case is expected to occur over the next few months. While further review by the Supreme Court is generally uncommon, RIM continues to believe this case raises significant national and international issues warranting further appellate review.

The Federal Circuit decision of August 2, 2005 vacated the injunction and damages award originally entered as a result of the District Court trial in 2002 and remanded the case to the District Court for further proceedings. The Federal Circuit decision also reversed or vacated the infringement finding on 9 of the 16 litigated patent claims.

During the upcoming proceedings, the District Court will be asked to decide a variety of matters relating to the litigation including the enforcement of the settlement agreement announced by the parties on March 16, 2005, the impact of the Patent Office re-examinations of the NTP patents on the litigation and the impact of the further proceedings ordered by the Federal Circuit in its August 2, 2005 ruling. RIM also expects NTP to ask the District Court to enter a new injunction prohibiting RIM from providing BlackBerry service and from using, selling, manufacturing or importing its handhelds and software in the United States. RIM expects the District Court will schedule briefings or hearings prior to deciding each of these matters. While RIM maintains that an injunction is inappropriate given the facts of the case and substantial doubts raised subsequent to trial as to the validity of the patents in question, it ultimately will be up to the courts to decide these matters and there can never be an assurance of a favorable outcome in any litigation.

The next step in the litigation is expected to be a scheduling conference between the parties and the District Court within the next few weeks to begin discussing the subject and timing of further briefings, hearings and other proceedings relating to all matters under consideration, including any potential motion for an injunction that NTP may decide to file.

All of the NTP patent claims have now been rejected by the Patent Office in its initial rulings in re-examination proceedings, based in part on prior art not considered in the District Court trial in 2002.


News Feed News Feed | Add to: Bloglines | MyYahoo! | Google | Facebook


Reader Comments (0)


Post a comment and discuss this story with other readers.




Top Stories


Nokia N85 Multimedia Device Announced Nokia N85 Multimedia Device Announced
Nokia N79 Smartphone Unveiled Nokia N79 Smartphone Unveiled
Nokia N96 Coming to North America Nokia N96 Coming to North America
AT&T Expands International Data Plans for Apple iPhone AT&T Expands International Data Plans for Apple iPhone
Verizon Wireless Blitz Offers QWERTY Keyboard Verizon Wireless Blitz Offers QWERTY Keyboard
Sony Ericsson TM506 HSDPA Phone Launched for T-Mobile Sony Ericsson TM506 HSDPA Phone Launched for T-Mobile
Palm Treo Pro Unveiled to Battle BlackBerry Palm Treo Pro Unveiled to Battle BlackBerry
LG Invision Brings AT&T Mobile TV LG Invision Brings AT&T Mobile TV
Apple Releases iPhone 3G Software Update to Fix Glitches Apple Releases iPhone 3G Software Update to Fix Glitches
Nokia Offers Lonely Planet Maps on Cell Phones Nokia Offers Lonely Planet Maps on Cell Phones


Find Free Phones
Free Cell Phones Free Cell Phones
Free Camera Phones Free Camera Phones
Free Smartphones Free Smartphones

News By Manufacturer

Apple News Apple News
Kyocera News Kyocera News
LG News LG News
Motorola News Motorola News
Nokia News Nokia News
Palm News Palm News
RIM News RIM News
Samsung News Samsung News
Sanyo News Sanyo News
Siemens News Siemens News
Sony Ericsson News Sony Ericsson News

News By Carrier

Alltel News Alltel News
AT&T News AT&T News
Cingular News Cingular News
Nextel News Nextel News
Sprint News Sprint News
T-Mobile News T-Mobile News
Verizon Wireless News Verizon Wireless News

Other News

Microsoft News Microsoft News
Symbian News Symbian News
Health & Safety News Health & Safety News

News Archive

2008

Cell Phone News - August 2008 Aug
Cell Phone News - July 2008 Jul
Cell Phone News - June 2008 Jun
Cell Phone News - May 2008 May
Cell Phone News - April 2008 Apr
Cell Phone News - March 2008 Mar

Cell Phone News - February 2008 Feb
Cell Phone News - January 2008 Jan

2007

Cell Phone News - December 2007 Dec
Cell Phone News - November 2007 Nov
Cell Phone News - October 2007 Oct
Cell Phone News - September 2007 Sep
Cell Phone News - August 2007 Aug
Cell Phone News - July 2007 Jul

Cell Phone News - June 2007 Jun
Cell Phone News - May 2007 May
Cell Phone News - April 2007 Apr
Cell Phone News - March 2007 Mar
Cell Phone News - February 2007 Feb
Cell Phone News - January 2007 Jan

2006

Cell Phone News - December 2006 Dec
Cell Phone News - November 2006 Nov
Cell Phone News - October 2006 Oct
Cell Phone News - September 2006 Sep
Cell Phone News - August 2006 Aug
Cell Phone News - July 2006 Jul

Cell Phone News - June 2006 Jun
Cell Phone News - May 2006 May
Cell Phone News - April 2006 Apr
Cell Phone News - March 2006 Mar
Cell Phone News - February 2006 Feb
Cell Phone News - January 2006 Jan

2005

Cell Phone News - December 2005 Dec
Cell Phone News - November 2005 Nov
Cell Phone News - October 2005 Oct
Cell Phone News - September 2005 Sep
Cell Phone News - August 2005 Aug
Cell Phone News - July 2005 Jul

Cell Phone News - June 2005 Jun
Cell Phone News - May 2005 May
Cell Phone News - April 2005 Apr
Cell Phone News - March 2005 Mar
Cell Phone News - February 2005 Feb
Cell Phone News - January 2005 Jan






Google
Web Mobiledia.com

©2002-2008 Mobiledia Corp. A Cell Phone Resource Site. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy