Mobiledia: Cell Phones
Trending: Strategies & Solutions | Apple | Legal | Reports | Google Follow Us:

Home > Mobile News > RIM News > Chief Justice Denies Stay in BlackBerry Case

Chief Justice Denies Stay in BlackBerry Case


By Allen Tsai | Thu Oct 27, 2005 3:43 am

The Supreme Court denied RIM's motion to stay further proceedings in the case until the U.S. Supreme Court decides whether it will accept an appeal of the decision in this case. The Supreme Court was not asked to, and did not decide, whether it ultimately will accept an appeal of the decision in this case. Rather, the Supreme Court merely decided that it would follow its normal course of allowing the District Court to decide whether and to what extent to continue the litigation in light of all relevant circumstances, including the prospect that the Supreme Court may decide to hear the case. The process by which the Supreme Court will decide whether to hear the case is expected to occur over the next few months. While further review by the Supreme Court is generally uncommon, RIM continues to believe this case raises significant national and international issues warranting further appellate review.

Top News

Consumers Protest Apple's Working Conditions

T-Mobile Offers Free 4G Phones for Valentine's Day

Sprint Comes Up Short on IPhone

Apple Not Improving Factory Conditions, Teen Worker Says

Hackers Get Greedy, Extorts Symantec

More News >
The Federal Circuit decision of August 2, 2005 vacated the injunction and damages award originally entered as a result of the District Court trial in 2002 and remanded the case to the District Court for further proceedings. The Federal Circuit decision also reversed or vacated the infringement finding on 9 of the 16 litigated patent claims.

During the upcoming proceedings, the District Court will be asked to decide a variety of matters relating to the litigation including the enforcement of the settlement agreement announced by the parties on March 16, 2005, the impact of the Patent Office re-examinations of the NTP patents on the litigation and the impact of the further proceedings ordered by the Federal Circuit in its August 2, 2005 ruling. RIM also expects NTP to ask the District Court to enter a new injunction prohibiting RIM from providing BlackBerry service and from using, selling, manufacturing or importing its handhelds and software in the United States. RIM expects the District Court will schedule briefings or hearings prior to deciding each of these matters. While RIM maintains that an injunction is inappropriate given the facts of the case and substantial doubts raised subsequent to trial as to the validity of the patents in question, it ultimately will be up to the courts to decide these matters and there can never be an assurance of a favorable outcome in any litigation.

The next step in the litigation is expected to be a scheduling conference between the parties and the District Court within the next few weeks to begin discussing the subject and timing of further briefings, hearings and other proceedings relating to all matters under consideration, including any potential motion for an injunction that NTP may decide to file.

All of the NTP patent claims have now been rejected by the Patent Office in its initial rulings in re-examination proceedings, based in part on prior art not considered in the District Court trial in 2002.


Posted In: RIM (340)


Related News


RIM Touts App World to Woo Developers

RIM Touts App World to Woo Developers

Tue Feb 07, 2012 12:06 pm | By
Research In Motion said its BlackBerry App World is thriving, aiming to lure developers as the struggling company bets on app selection to help fuel its turnaround.




Advertisement



RIM Lures Android Developers with Free PlayBooks

RIM Lures Android Developers with Free PlayBooks

Fri Feb 03, 2012 11:02 am | By
Research In Motion is offering free BlackBerry PlayBooks to Android developers, as the struggling company tries to boost apps for its stumbling platform.




RIM to Change Direction with BlackBerry London

RIM to Change Direction with BlackBerry London

Wed Feb 01, 2012 1:24 pm | By
RIM's BlackBerry London offers "significant changes," including a new design and OS 10, as the struggling company bets big to regain its former luster.




RIM Promises "Significant" Changes with Carriers, Licensing

RIM Promises "Significant" Changes with Carriers, Licensing

Mon Jan 30, 2012 12:15 pm | By
New Research in Motion CEO Thorsten Heins promises "significant changes" for the company, but its struggles in the market likely need an overhaul beyond what the CEO hints for the future.




The Score: RIM, Nokia Offer a Tale of Two Comebacks

The Score: RIM, Nokia Offer a Tale of Two Comebacks

Fri Jan 27, 2012 1:58 pm | By
Two once-powerful tech companies took strong steps toward their comeback efforts, with Research In Motion replacing its co-CEOs and Nokia beginning its push of a new Windows phone.



Related Phones


RIM BlackBerry Bold (9930) RIM BlackBerry Torch (9850) RIM BlackBerry Curve (9370) RIM BlackBerry Curve (9360) RIM BlackBerry Curve (9350)
RIM BlackBerry Bold (9930) RIM BlackBerry Torch (9850) RIM BlackBerry Curve (9370) RIM BlackBerry Curve (9360) RIM BlackBerry Curve (9350)
Sprint / Verizon Verizon Verizon T-Mobile Sprint / Verizon

More Phones: BlackBerry


Editorials & Opinion

ITTO: Grammys Pull in Audiences with Apps, Mobile Campaign

By Margaret Rock
ITTO: Grammys Pull in Audiences with Apps, Mobile Campaign The 54th Grammy Awards is just days away, and the show will harness mobile and social media technology as old media tries to keep pace with new trends among its viewing audience.
The Future of mHealth: Healthcare Apps to Lower Insurance Costs The Future of mHealth: Healthcare Apps to Lower Insurance Costs
The Future of mHealth: Doctors Use Gadgets to Improve Healthcare The Future of mHealth: Doctors Use Gadgets to Improve Healthcare
The Future of mHealth: Putting Patients in the Driver's Seat The Future of mHealth: Putting Patients in the Driver's Seat

Follow Us

Mobiledia.com RSS Feed Mobiledia on Google+ Mobiledia on Tumblr

Mobiledia News In Your Inbox





Most Popular


Companies News

Apple News Apple News
AT&T News AT&T News
Google News Google News
HP News HP News
HTC News HTC News
LG News LG News
Microsoft News Microsoft News
Motorola News Motorola News
Nokia News Nokia News
RIM News RIM News
Samsung News Samsung News
Sony Ericsson News Sony Ericsson News
Sprint News Sprint News
T-Mobile News T-Mobile News
Verizon News Verizon News

Editorials & Opinion

Is This Thing On? Is This Thing On?
News Under the Sun News Under the Sun
The Score The Score

Business News

Finance News Finance News
Mergers & Acquisitions News Mergers & Acquisitions News
Politics News Politics News
Strategies & Solutions News Strategies & Solutions News

Gadgets & Gear News

Innovations & 
Inventions News Innovations & Inventions News
Luxury News Luxury News
New Releases New Releases

Legal News

Patents News Patents News
Policy News Policy News
Regulation News Regulation News

Lifestyle News

Arts & Entertainment News Arts & Entertainment News
Health & Safety News Health & Safety News
Off-Beat News Off-Beat News

Mobile News

Apps & Games News Apps & Games News
Mobile Payments News Mobile Payments News

Problems & Issues News

Crime & Punishment News Crime & Punishment News
Hacking News Hacking News
Viruses & Malware News Viruses & Malware News

Social Media News

Facebook News Facebook News
Twitter News Twitter News

News by Date

2011

Mobile News - January 2011 Jan
Mobile News - February 2011 Feb
Mobile News - March 2011 Mar
Mobile News - April 2011 Apr
Mobile News - May 2011 May
Mobile News - June 2011 Jun

Mobile News - July 2011 Jul
Mobile News - August 2011 Aug
Mobile News - September 2011 Sep
Mobile News - October 2011 Oct
Mobile News - November 2011 Nov
Mobile News - December 2011 Dec

2010

Mobile News - January 2010 Jan
Mobile News - February 2010 Feb
Mobile News - March 2010 Mar
Mobile News - April 2010 Apr
Mobile News - May 2010 May
Mobile News - June 2010 Jun

Mobile News - July 2010 Jul
Mobile News - August 2010 Aug
Mobile News - September 2010 Sep
Mobile News - October 2010 Oct
Mobile News - November 2010 Nov
Mobile News - December 2010 Dec

2009

Mobile News - January 2009 Jan
Mobile News - February 2009 Feb
Mobile News - March 2009 Mar
Mobile News - April 2009 Apr
Mobile News - May 2009 May
Mobile News - June 2009 Jun

Mobile News - July 2009 Jul
Mobile News - August 2009 Aug
Mobile News - September 2009 Sep
Mobile News - October 2009 Oct
Mobile News - November 2009 Nov
Mobile News - December 2009 Dec

2008

Mobile News - January 2008 Jan
Mobile News - February 2008 Feb
Mobile News - March 2008 Mar
Mobile News - April 2008 Apr
Mobile News - May 2008 May
Mobile News - June 2008 Jun

Mobile News - July 2008 Jul
Mobile News - August 2008 Aug
Mobile News - September 2008 Sep
Mobile News - October 2008 Oct
Mobile News - November 2008 Nov
Mobile News - December 2008 Dec

2007

Mobile News - January 2007 Jan
Mobile News - February 2007 Feb
Mobile News - March 2007 Mar
Mobile News - April 2007 Apr
Mobile News - May 2007 May
Mobile News - June 2007 Jun

Mobile News - July 2007 Jul
Mobile News - August 2007 Aug
Mobile News - September 2007 Sep
Mobile News - October 2007 Oct
Mobile News - November 2007 Nov
Mobile News - December 2007 Dec

2006

Mobile News - January 2006 Jan
Mobile News - February 2006 Feb
Mobile News - March 2006 Mar
Mobile News - April 2006 Apr
Mobile News - May 2006 May
Mobile News - June 2006 Jun

Mobile News - July 2006 Jul
Mobile News - August 2006 Aug
Mobile News - September 2006 Sep
Mobile News - October 2006 Oct
Mobile News - November 2006 Nov
Mobile News - December 2006 Dec



©2002-2012 Mobiledia Corp. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy